• Judy Asks: Is Renzi’s Italy Back in the EU Game?

    Posted by: Judy Dempsey October 01, 2014

    Every week, a selection of leading experts answer a new question from Judy Dempsey on the foreign and security policy challenges shaping Europe’s role in the world.


    Federiga BindiSenior fellow at the Center for Transatlantic Relations at the Johns Hopkins School of Advanced International Studies

    Is Italy in the EU game now? Was it out before? The answer to both questions is “not really.” For a long time, Italy was always in, and yet never in.

    Italy’s influence in EU decisionmaking is that of a medium-sized power, not of a big country. This has been the case for years, and it will take several Matteo Renzis and a serious revolution in the country’s domestic institutions to change the status quo. The previous two governments had taken serious strides in this direction, but is not clear whether the momentum is still there.

    If being back in the game means having Italian Foreign Minister Federica Mogherini named as the EU’s foreign policy chief, then the question is what price Italy will pay for the appointment, which was unconventional by the normal standards of EU horse-trading. It is also unclear whether Mogherini will really be able to influence the decisions that matter—that is, economic policies. Incoming European Commission President Jean-Claude Juncker seems to have clear ideas about who is boss.

    And what if persistent rumors are true that former Italian prime minister Enrico Letta was a widely supported candidate for the post of president of the European Council? If that is the case, then Italy lost the chance to have an additional key EU position by not pushing Letta’s candidacy, as the country that gets the job of European Council president must still nominate a European commissioner, just as all other member states.

    Renzi is charming and a great communicator. Whether there is substance too in Renzi’s Italy, only time will tell.


    Marta DassùEditor of Aspenia at the Aspen Institute Italia

    How exactly do you define the “EU game”? If the aim of the game is to change the EU’s economic policy, then Italy’s influence is limited.

    Thanks to a robust performance in May’s European Parliament elections, Italian Prime Minister Matteo Renzi’s strength is remarkable. But this does not suffice, and neither does Italy’s holding of the rotating presidency of the EU Council. Much of Renzi’s approval rating will depend on his delivery of an agenda of domestic reforms. In the absence of an economic rebound, any Italian ambition to project influence on an EU scale will remain short-lived. Renzi’s greatest challenge is therefore a domestic one.

    At home, Renzi still enjoys strong popular support. Moreover, he is proving capable of keeping both his own Democratic Party and his thin bipartisan parliamentary majority under control. And yet, Renzi suffers from a poor legislative record. Solving this “execution dilemma” is crucial—for Italy and for Europe. The approval of Italy’s “jobs act,” which aims to reform employment law, will be a key test.

    On another front, EU foreign policy, Renzi got what he wanted: Italian Foreign Minister Federica Mogherini in charge of EU foreign policy. That is good. Major actors, however, perceive this part of the “EU game” as less relevant than economic issues. This is a mistaken assumption, given the importance of geopolitical risks, and a belief that Mogherini will have to prove wrong.


    Silvia FrancesconHead of the Rome office of the European Council on Foreign Relations

    The Italy of Prime Minister Matteo Renzi certainly appears to be back in the EU game; that is what recent high-profile events would suggest, at least. But it is one thing to be visible, another to be influential and play a leadership role.

    So far, Renzi and Renzi’s Italy (perhaps the first more than the second) have been quite visible in the EU, for two main reasons.

    First, the European Parliament elections in May 2014 proved that Italy is not the naughty boy that many claimed it was. Italian voter turnout was one of the highest in Europe. Renzi’s Democratic Party gained an unexpected 41 percent of the vote and now has the biggest delegation of members of parliament in the pan-European Socialist group. And Renzi was one of the few European political leaders to contain the Euroskeptic surge that swept many other EU member states.

    Second, Italy obtained the post of EU foreign policy high representative, one of the most visible EU jobs. Securing the appointment of Italian Foreign Minister Federica Mogherini to the position was a personal victory for Renzi, who prevailed against the opposition of several member states.

    This is all good news for Italy. However, the real challenge is another one.

    Italy has lost much of its influence in recent years due to many factors, especially the country’s weak economic performance. Renzi’s real task is to place Italy at the forefront of the EU. That means implementing reforms at home, something in which both Mario Monti and Enrico Letta—Renzi’s predecessors—failed.

    The answer to the question of whether Italy is back in the EU game will become clear only after Rome implements wide-ranging reforms and takes concrete steps to fight tax evasion and corruption. This has all yet to come.


    Gianni RiottaMember of the Council on Foreign Relations

    Yes. Matteo Renzi’s predecessors as prime minister of Italy, Mario Monti and Enrico Letta, managed to repair much of the diplomatic damage caused by Silvio Berlusconi’s hectic final days in office. But they failed to break the austerity choke hold imposed on Italy by Germany.

    Renzi, by contrast, is playing an entirely different ball game. Acutely aware—his political instincts are keen—of the raging populist waves, Renzi has raised the ante against European antigrowth rules. He has then mobilized his own base in Italy while garnering support from across the Old Continent.

    Will this be enough to mollify German Chancellor Angela Merkel? Not at all; Renzi needs to build a credible dialogue with French President François Hollande, an early lame duck, while maintaining a viable relationship with postcrisis leaders in Spain and Greece. By engaging in conversation with Poland and the Baltics, Rome has a chance to swap its old economic sympathies for fresh geopolitical worries.

    Alas, all of Renzi’s political and diplomatic maneuvers, together with his clubbable personality, will not be enough. Italy badly needs reforms, and in the long term, that is the only thing that will sustain the country’s newfound leadership role in Brussels.


  • A Battle Plan for NATO’s New Secretary General

    Posted by: Jan Techau Tuesday, September 30, 2014 2

    NATO’s new boss, Jens Stoltenberg, enters office at a crucial time of strategic positioning for the alliance. He has a number of difficult tasks ahead of him.

  • NATO Stays Far Away From the Islamic State

    Posted by: Judy Dempsey Monday, September 29, 2014 1

    NATO has been almost completely absent in the debate about how to deal with the Islamic State. That is down to a number of fundamental differences among members of the alliance.

  • Time for Mayor Power

    Posted by: Misha Glenny Friday, September 26, 2014 1

    Publics increasingly want to place their faith in people whose work they can understand and scrutinize directly. Could a bigger role for mayors be the answer?

  • Russia Is (Again) Persecuting the Crimean Tatars

    Posted by: Judy Dempsey Thursday, September 25, 2014

    Since the West acquiesced over Russia’s illegal annexation of Crimea, Moscow has a free hand to pressurize and intimidate the peninsula’s Tatars.

  • Judy Asks: What on Earth Is Turkey Up to?

    Posted by: Judy Dempsey Wednesday, September 24, 2014 1

    Every week, a selection of leading experts answer a new question from Judy Dempsey on the foreign and security policy challenges shaping Europe’s role in the world.

  • The West’s Negative Downward Spiral Psycho Trap

    Posted by: Jan Techau Tuesday, September 23, 2014 1

    Many voices have lamented the West’s impending decline. That apprehension is misplaced, as the decline is imagined: the only thing the West has to fear is fear itself.

  • Tensions on the Turkish Border

    Posted by: Marc Pierini Monday, September 22, 2014

    Chaos has descended along Turkey’s frontier with Syria. That raises a number of questions about Ankara’s efforts to combat the Islamic State militants.

  • Europe’s New Frozen Conflict

    Posted by: Judy Dempsey Monday, September 22, 2014 1

    A buffer zone in eastern Ukraine perpetuates Russia’s influence over that part of the country—and over Ukrainian politics.

  • Now David Cameron Can Make History

    Posted by: Jan Techau Friday, September 19, 2014 1

    British Prime Minister David Cameron has been given the opportunity to fundamentally reshape the political landscape of a country toward a more modern design.

  • Scotland Votes No to Independence

    Posted by: Judy Dempsey Friday, September 19, 2014 2

    Now that Scotland has voted to remain in the UK, Britain has to decide if it wants to remain in Europe.

  • If the Scottish Nationalists Win, What Does London Lose?

    Posted by: Alyson Bailes Thursday, September 18, 2014

    As Scots go to the polls to vote on whether to leave the United Kingdom, it is clear that well-founded fears lie behind the possibility of an independent Scotland.

  • Judy Asks: Has Obama Finally Discovered Foreign Policy?

    Posted by: Judy Dempsey Wednesday, September 17, 2014

    Every week, a selection of leading experts answer a new question from Judy Dempsey on the foreign and security policy challenges shaping Europe’s role in the world.

  • Why the EU Will Fail as Ukraine’s Guarantor

    Posted by: Jan Techau Tuesday, September 16, 2014 4

    For the first time in its history, the EU has become a regional guarantee power. Yet the union and its member states so far lack the capacity to maintain that role in the long term.

  • The West Is Not Prepared for the Long Haul Over Ukraine

    Posted by: Judy Dempsey Monday, September 15, 2014 6

    The Kremlin is weakening Ukraine’s independence and eroding other parts of Eastern Europe. The West lacks the long-term resolve to deal with Russia’s actions.

  • Taking the Temperature in Brussels

    Posted by: Roderick Parkes Friday, September 12, 2014 1

    Amid the excitement over the appointment of the next generation of EU leaders, a curious and eclectic lexicon has emerged among the inhabitants of the Brussels bubble.

  • The Return of the European Commission to Foreign Policy Making?

    Posted by: Marc Pierini Thursday, September 11, 2014 1

    The incoming president of the European Commission, Jean-Claude Juncker, hopes to improve foreign policy coordination among the EU institutions. That is a laudable aim.

  • Ukraine Is Changing the Post–Cold War World

    Posted by: Judy Dempsey Thursday, September 11, 2014 2

    The Ukraine crisis is set to have a profound effect on how the West, particularly Germany and the United States, delineates its foreign policy responsibilities.

  • The New European Commission: Inward- or Outward-Looking?

    Posted by: Judy Dempsey Wednesday, September 10, 2014

    As Jean-Claude Juncker unveils his new European Commission, he has chosen to make domestic economic issues his priority. Foreign policy looks set to play second fiddle.

  • Judy Asks: Should Scotland Be an Independent Country?

    Posted by: Judy Dempsey Wednesday, September 10, 2014 2

    Every week, a selection of leading experts answer a new question from Judy Dempsey on the foreign and security policy challenges shaping Europe’s role in the world.


About Strategic Europe

Judy Dempsey’s Strategic Europe offers insightful analysis, fresh commentary, and concrete policy recommendations from some of Europe’s keenest international affairs observers.

Subscribe Today

Sign up to receive Judy Dempsey's Strategic Europe updates in your inbox! Fields marked with an asterisk (*) are required.

Sign up to receive Strategic Europe updates in your inbox!
Carnegie Europe
Carnegie Europe Rue du Congrès, 15 1000 Brussels, Belgium Phone: +32 2 735 56 50 Fax: +32 2736 6222
Please note...

You are leaving the Carnegie–Tsinghua Center for Global Policy's website and entering another Carnegie global site.


您离开卡内基 - 清华全球政策中心网站,进入另一个卡内基全球网站。